Your go-to shoe says more about you than your zodiac sign. And before all of you astrological fanatics come after me, please hear me out. Shoes offer a glimpse into your personality, whether you’re the type who prefers comfort over aesthetic or even classic styles over trends. Unlike zodiac signs that stay the same your whole life, your go-to shoe can change from year to year, not tying you down to one trait or quirk. Eventually, you have to retire shoes as they wear down or as your feet grow. And while you can buy the same pair, you have the opportunity to mix things up, and I don’t think you can say the same about your sign.

I recently switched up my go-to shoe. Last winter, I would die for my New Balance 327s that I bought while visiting my friends studying abroad in London. They saved me from blisters and sore soles that would’ve ruined my trip. (For whatever reason, I only packed boots for London, and I’m as equally confused as you are.) I’ve always loved wearing New Balance shoes because of the “N” on the side. When I was younger, my dad told me the “N” stood for Nina, my name, and from there, they became my go-to shoe.

But this winter, I looked at my New Balances at the bottom of my closet and thought to myself, these don’t fit my personality anymore. I wanted a shoe that was still me, but a little mysterious. A shoe that suggests I could be passionate like a fire sign or grounded like an earth sign. A shoe that represents a girl who has a never-ending TBR, a soft spot for craft nights, or even a collection of refrigerator magnets. I desired a pair that could match both my feminine and masculine sides.

After endless scrolling on Pinterest and TikTok, I decided the 1461 Bex Smooth Leather Oxford Shoes by Dr. Martens were the perfect fit. I’ve been wearing them to work, to class, on nights out, and to the library. They match every nook and cranny of my personality–at least, for my current personality.